Lustich All Articles
Lists & Pop Culture

We Ate Every Fast Food Fry in America So You Don't Have To (You're Welcome, Society)

By Lustich Lists & Pop Culture
We Ate Every Fast Food Fry in America So You Don't Have To (You're Welcome, Society)

Let's be honest with ourselves for a moment. Nobody needs a french fry ranking. The world is not lacking in hot takes about potato sticks. And yet — here we are, because some questions demand answers, and the question of which fast food chain makes the superior fry is apparently one that a significant portion of the American population loses sleep over.

We know this because we asked. We put out a call on social media for fry opinions, expecting maybe a few dozen responses. What we got was 847 submissions, four voice memos from strangers, and one handwritten letter — yes, physical mail — from a man in Tulsa named Gerald who described Arby's curly fries as "a spiritual experience." Gerald, this one's for you.

Here, then, is the definitive, exhaustive, mildly unhinged ranking of fast food french fries in America, compiled by people who took this way more seriously than any reasonable adult should.

The Methodology (And We Use That Word Loosely)

Our crack team of volunteer tasters — three coworkers, one suspicious friend-of-a-friend, and a guy named Derek who just happened to be in the parking lot — evaluated each fry on the following criteria:

Each taster was asked to rate fries on a scale of 1–10. Derek rated everything a 7 because, as he explained, "I'm a seven guy." Derek's scores were adjusted accordingly.

The Rankings: From Potato Tragedy to Potato Glory

🥔 Last Place: Burger King Fries

We're sorry. We really are. But the people have spoken, and they spoke with the weary resignation of someone who has been let down too many times. BK fries arrive with a promising exterior — golden, thick-ish, seemingly confident — and then you bite into one and realize they are, in fact, hollow inside, both literally and emotionally. Several tasters described the experience as "eating a fry-shaped concept." One submission simply read: "Why are they always soggy? Why? WHY?" We don't have answers. We only have rankings.

🥔 Fifth Place: Wendy's Fries

Wendy's has been on a fry redemption arc ever since they switched to their sea-salted, skin-on situation a few years back, and we respect the hustle. The problem is consistency. Sometimes you get a batch that's crispy, flavorful, and genuinely exciting. Other times you get a pile of beige regret. The skin-on aesthetic scores points for personality, but personality alone doesn't win a fry ranking. We're not here to make friends. We're here to eat potatoes.

🥔 Fourth Place: Chick-fil-A Waffle Fries

Now before you type an angry comment, hear us out. Chick-fil-A waffle fries are excellent. They're crispy, they're structurally magnificent, and their surface area makes them arguably the greatest dipping vehicle in fast food history. The reason they land at four is simple: they are not available on Sundays. This is not a neutral fact. This is a personality flaw. When America craves waffle fries, America does not check the calendar first. Points deducted. Non-negotiable.

🥔 Third Place: Arby's Curly Fries

Gerald from Tulsa, your moment has arrived. Curly fries are a different category of fry entirely — they're seasoned, they're spiraled, they're chaotic in the best possible way. Arby's curly fries taste like someone looked at a regular fry and said, "What if this had ambition?" They pair beautifully with Arby's sauce (a condiment that deserves its own ranking article, frankly) and they maintain their structural integrity under pressure. The only reason they're not higher is that they're technically showing off, and we have a soft spot for understated excellence.

🥔 Second Place: Five Guys Fries

Five Guys fries are what happens when a fast food chain decides to simply not compromise. Fresh-cut, cooked in peanut oil, aggressively salted, and served in quantities that suggest the restaurant is actively concerned about your sodium intake — these fries are a commitment. You don't order Five Guys fries. You enter into a relationship with Five Guys fries. The only reason they're not number one is price point and the fact that you'll receive roughly 400 of them whether you want 400 or not. The overflow fries at the bottom of the bag are both a blessing and a curse.

🥔 First Place: McDonald's Fries

Did you see this coming? Of course you did. And yet somehow it still feels right. McDonald's fries are the platonic ideal of the fast food fry — thin, impossibly salty, aggressively crispy for approximately four minutes after being handed to you, and then gradually declining into something softer and sadder, like the rest of us. They are not the most sophisticated fry. They are not the most adventurous fry. They are, however, the fry that lives in your memory. The fry you think about at 11pm. The fry that, when you smell it from across a food court, makes you briefly forget all your problems. That's not nothing. That's everything.

The Heated Reader Opinion Section (Buckle Up)

We promised to include reader submissions, and we are nothing if not journalists of our word. Here is a small, representative sample of the passionate discourse your fellow Americans submitted:

"Sonic's tots should be in this conversation and I will die on this hill." — Anonymous, Michigan

"McDonald's fries are only good for four minutes. That's not a fry, that's a window of opportunity." — Kevin R., Phoenix

"Shake Shack fries are crinkle cut and they're PERFECT and your list is INCOMPLETE." — Someone who signed their email with three exclamation points

"I once drove 45 minutes specifically for Five Guys fries. My therapist knows about this." — Unnamed, for obvious reasons

We hear you, Kevin. We see you, Shake Shack enthusiast. And to the person who emailed us a 900-word essay arguing that Popeyes' cajun fries are criminally underrated — you're right, and we're sorry we didn't have room for an honorable mentions section.

The Takeaway (Pun Fully Intended)

At the end of the day — and at the end of approximately 4,000 calories of field research — what we learned is this: Americans do not take french fries lightly. We take them personally. Our fry preferences are tied to memory, to geography, to that one road trip where the only thing open was a Sonic and honestly? The tots were incredible.

Fries are not just a side dish. They are a statement. They are a lifestyle. They are, apparently, something 847 people will write to a humor website about unprompted.

Gerald from Tulsa, we hope we did you proud.

Think we got it wrong? Of course you do. Drop your ranking in the comments and prepare to be judged.